You may remember that I won this CD (actually 2 CDs) recently from Amnesty International, as long as I posted a review about it on my blog. So here it is.
I should first of all mention that all the songs on this CD are covers by different bands of John Lennon's songs. Unfortunately, I don't know much of John Lennon's discography outside of the Beatles, so this review considers the songs as songs in their own right, not covers.
Overall, I think this was quite a good album, with moments of brilliance. The whole album seems to have undercurrents of hippyness and humanism, which I relate to. It makes me regret missing the 60s and 70s really; it's too late to be a hippy these days...
There were several big names on this CD, some that I approved of (U2, REM, Aerosmith), some that I didn't (Christina Aguilera, Corinne Bailey Rae, Black Eye Peas) as well as a few bands I'd only vaguely heard of (Postal Service, Youssou N'Dour) and some artists I didn't know of at all (Regina Spektor, Big & Rich).
The big names definitely did not disappoint. Instant Karma by U2 and #9 Dream by REM were both great to listen to, and Snow Patrol's Isolation was haunting. Aerosmith's Give Peace A Chance featured Sierra Leone's Refugee All Stars, which I thing was a brilliant touch politically and for the song. Their chorus was incredibly cheery and lovely to listen to, making the song one of my favourites. Politically, these kind of music-politics mergers are often criticized for not having many African artists, so it was good to involve the All Stars as well as Youssou N'Dour (who you may remember from Live 8).
Green Day's cover of Working Class Hero was truly spectacular; not only a powerful song, but also a strong message about class that reverberates even stronger in today's society. In fact, among the big names, only The Cure's cover of love disappointed me slightly for being a little dull.
A pleasant surprise for me was that not all the artists I dislike were actually that bad. Black Eyed Pea's power to the people was okay, and Corinne Bailey Rae's I'm Losing You was, well, different but not terrible. Only Christina Aguilera's screechy rendition of Mother made me wish to skip tracks.
Perhaps the best part of the CD was that most of the artists I hadn't heard of were fantastic. For instance, Lenny Kravitz's Cold Turkey is simple but powerful, and his voice really fits the song.
One of the criticisms of the album is that there are multiple versions of some songs. There are 3 Instant Karmas, 2 Imagines and 2 #9 Dreams. However, I found it quite nice to get a few different versions of each song; only Duran Duran's version of Instant Karma seemed a bit excessive and pointless. Tokio Hotel, meanwhile, managed to introduce heavier guitars to Instant Karma, which I found wonderful.
Imagine by Avril Lavigne was a little high-pitched for me, but John Jackson's version more than made up for this. His voice was perfect for the song, and it not only made my skin tingle, but also almost made me cry thinking about the contrast between the words and humanity today - particularly Darfur. That song was the highlight of the album for me.
Overall, the album is very hearable. A few let downs - Christina Aguilera should not have been involved, and Regina Spektor finishes with a sickeningly Disney-like cover of Real Love - are much more than made up for by the assortment of good tracks, and the several outstanding songs that you can't help but love. And, of course, proceeds go to ending the suffering in Darfur, so it's good for your Karma too.